Debating the Best Way to Track Small-Business Lending

A broker assesses the small-business lending market.

In a recent post, I introduced my company’s effort to grade American banks on their small-business lending activity.

The Financial Services Roundtable, an association that represents some of the largest banks in America, has taken issue with our grading system. We decided to have a discussion with the organization — and share it with our readers — in the hope that it might bring some clarity to the important issue of whether big banks are committed to lending to small businesses.

A big part of the discussion involves what constitutes a small-business loan. On our report cards, we calculated the grades as a ratio of the banks’ domestic deposits to their small-business loan balances — which we define, as does the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, as those with a balance of $1 million or less. By contrast, when the big banks issue their own small-business lending report cards, they define loans as those made to companies with revenue of $20 million or less.

As we dug into our debate, we learned that business credit card balances are included in the small-business loans that banks report to the F.D.I.C. We realized this after the big banks defended their small-business lending records by stating that they held 80 percent of all the loans under $100,000. But the average balance of these loans is just $6,323 — which raises an interesting question: Is it fair for the big banks to equate credit card lending with the much more rigorous process of qualifying a business for a more substantial loan with a balance of, say, $100,000 to $1 million?

For the complete story, click here.

Tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply